The International Court of Justice stands this week on the edge of a decision that would reshape its own institutional history. The World Court, as the Hague-based body is also known, is expected to rule in the landmark genocide case against Myanmar later this week. It has never before formally found a country guilty of committing genocide. For an institution whose mandate rests on states accepting its jurisdiction, the judgment will be a test of what its authority can actually deliver.
The case was filed in 2019 by Gambia, a predominantly Muslim West African nation, which accused Myanmar of committing genocide against the Rohingya, a mainly Muslim minority from the remote western state of Rakhine. The charge traces back to 2017, when Myanmar’s armed forces launched an offensive that forced at least 730,000 Rohingya from their homes and into neighboring Bangladesh, where survivors recounted killings, mass rape, and arson.
Accountability advocates have framed the moment as a chance to correct an earlier failure of international oversight. Yanghee Lee, a former UN rights investigator to Myanmar, told The Guardian that the ruling would be historic for Rohingya survivors and their families around the world. “The international community failed to prevent Myanmar military atrocities against the Rohingya nine years ago. It must seize this opportunity to finally secure justice for the Rohingya and begin to reckon with these failings,” she said.
The court’s record on genocide is thin, and the coming ruling must be read against it. Before Gambia brought the Myanmar case, the ICJ had rarely handled questions of genocide at all. In 2007, the court ruled that Serbia had failed to prevent the 1995 genocide at Srebrenica in Bosnia and Herzegovina, yet it declined to hold any single country directly responsible for the crime. In 2022, Ukraine brought a case to the court days after Russia’s invasion, contesting accusations that it was itself committing genocide in Luhansk and Donetsk. The ICJ has never issued a genocide conviction, though other international legal institutions have. The Hague hosted war crime tribunals for Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, and the International Criminal Court holds jurisdiction over genocide cases. A key constraint on the World Court is that cases can only be brought where both countries have consented to its jurisdiction, as they have under the Genocide Convention. Russia, Myanmar, and Israel are all parties to that convention.
The implications of the ruling are expected to reach well beyond Myanmar, and this is where the accountability questions multiply. The outcome will likely affect South Africa’s genocide case against Israel at the ICJ over the war in Gaza. It was Gambia’s genocide charge against Myanmar that supplied the precedent South Africa relied on when it brought its own accusation before the court. South Africa filed its case against Israel in December 2023, alleging violations of the Genocide Convention in relation to the war in Gaza. Israel rejected the allegation, calling it baseless.
The case has also drawn intervention from senior officials in the United States. US Ambassador to the UN Mike Waltz warned in an October post on X, formerly Twitter, against allowing the ICJ to lower the legal threshold for proving genocide. He argued that a weakened and false standard could later be weaponized against American and allied soldiers whenever they raise a finger against terrorists that hide behind civilians. His comments underline a tension that runs through the entire proceedings: the same legal standard being tested in the Myanmar case is one that powerful states fear could be turned against them.
That tension is precisely what makes this week’s ruling a matter of institutional consequence rather than a single-country verdict. If the court finds Myanmar responsible, it will establish that a state can be held directly liable for genocide within its own borders, a standard that would then sit on the record for every future case, including South Africa’s against Israel. If it stops short, the court will have confirmed the limits of its reach, and the gap between international legal obligation and enforceable accountability will remain as wide as it was after Srebrenica.
Either way, the decision will define the boundaries of the World Court’s power at a moment when several governments are watching closely to see how far that power extends, and whether the judgment they await can be enforced at all.