Minister orders SASCOC task team to stabilise Swimming SA

Minister orders SASCOC task team to stabilise Swimming SA

Probe will examine Arena deal, withheld prize money and federation funding gaps

Sport Minister Gayton McKenzie has instructed the South African Sports Confederation, Olympic and Paralympic Committee (SASCOC) to investigate Swimming South Africa (SSA) and deploy a task team to stabilise the federation, after detailing how the country’s most decorated Olympian, Tatjana Smith, was fined 46,000 euros and had her prize money withheld before announcing she would swim for the Netherlands.

The order to SASCOC is the operational centre of the story. McKenzie asked the confederation to establish how SSA’s deal with Arena works, what penalties were levied and who paid them, and whether other swimmers were fined or had money held back. The probe must also examine spending on the Franschhoek High Performance Centre, flaws in the federation’s constitution, and why swimmers are choosing other countries.

McKenzie was explicit about the limits of his own authority in the delivery chain. “The law says SASCOC must deal with this first,” he said. “I cannot act against SSA immediately. If I could, I would have acted against this board already.”

Speaking at a press briefing on Tuesday, the minister set out the sequence of events as Smith has described them. At the 2023 World Championships in Fukuoka, Smith swam in her own sponsor’s suit and goggles with the federation’s official cap, as she had done since 2019. On the morning of her first 100m heat, she was handed a letter from SSA’s chief executive warning that any swimmer not wearing the sponsor’s brand would be penalised automatically, at 2,000 euros per heat and 20,000 euros per final, with no hearing. She swam anyway, winning gold in the 200m and silver in the 100m. Those medals carried US$35,000 in prize money, paid by World Aquatics to the federation to pass on to the athlete.

Three weeks later, Smith received a one-line email with an invoice for 46,000 euros for “Arena infringement”, more than she had won, and the federation held on to her prize money. In May 2024, two months before the Paris Olympics, she had to instruct lawyers to recover her own money. Only then was it paid. Interest was only paid this year.

McKenzie said the undisputed facts were that Smith never signed SSA’s deal with Arena, there was no disciplinary hearing, and none of the process required by the federation’s own rules was followed. He said SSA has since withdrawn the fine and its acting leadership had admitted to Parliament that it should never have happened. “The message to every athlete is: if you are wronged, keep quiet,” he said.

The minister framed the saga as a failure of how sport is funded and run, not of athlete support alone. He said the department was never designed to be the main funder of all sport. It funds more than 60 bodies, but that money is for basics: an office, staff and development. It may not pay board members. Federations were expected to raise their own money from events, sponsors and membership fees. Government does not book athletes’ flights. If South Africans expect the department to fund all sport, he would have to ask Treasury for potentially hundreds of millions more.

By contrast, the Netherlands runs an elite budget of about 68-million euros a year, funded by the lottery and sports ministry, with more than 21-million euros going straight to athletes. McKenzie also said he would raise tax incentives for sport sponsorship with the Minister of Finance. Currently, a donation to a school can be deducted from tax, but the same donation to a federation gets no recognition.

On claims that Smith was abandoned, McKenzie said these were not the full story. Government had rewarded her for her Tokyo medals, named her Sport Star of the Year, and over her career South Africa had paid her more than an estimated R3-million in incentives and prize money. “Is that enough? No. You cannot put a price on that kind of talent,” he said.

Smith’s decision, he stressed, was her own. She holds two passports, told him personally before her announcement, and nothing could undo her two Olympic gold medals and four medals in all for South Africa. “The question is not whether she should have stayed, but how do we fix what made the choice for her,” McKenzie said.

The briefing also surfaced wider problems in the delivery of sport. McKenzie said he found federations that received millions and never reported how the money was spent. Some had no offices. Some were run out of the boot of a car. He listed unprecedented suspensions: the presidents of Netball SA, Athletics SA and SASCOC, and the president and CEO of Swimming SA provisionally suspended by World Aquatics. None was a finding of guilt.

“For decades, a small group have treated our federations as if they owned them. That era is ending,” he said.

To Smith, he had a direct message: “Thank you, and go well. We are fixing this, so that the next Tatjana never has to choose. Re tla e lokisa. We will fix this.”

Q&A

What has the minister asked SASCOC to investigate about Swimming South Africa?

Establish how SSA's deal with Arena works, what penalties were levied and who paid them, whether other swimmers were fined or had money withheld, spending on the Franschhoek High Performance Centre, flaws in the federation's constitution, and why swimmers are choosing other countries.

What happened to Tatjana Smith's prize money after Fukuoka?

She was fined 46,000 euros for wearing her own sponsor's suit and goggles, received a one-line invoice three weeks after the 2023 Fukuoka championships, and had her US$35,000 prize money withheld; she had to instruct lawyers in May 2024 to recover her own money, with interest only paid this year.

Does the department fully fund South African sport?

No. The department funds more than 60 bodies but only for basics such as an office, staff and development; it may not pay board members or athletes' flights, and full funding would require asking Treasury for potentially hundreds of millions more.

How does the Netherlands fund elite sport by comparison?

The Netherlands runs an elite budget of about 68-million euros a year, funded by the lottery and sports ministry, with more than 21-million euros going directly to athletes.